Ever submitted your tracks to curators ?
Have you ever wondered about what reaction you would get if you sent your music to a professional curator ? So I sent my latest release to Groover, you can listen here, then check the feedback below
I have also done this through independent Facebook music groups and received good comments, but we are there to support each other and criticism is not that harsh. Though you get good ideas info on mixing, content and structure etc. so worth doing. Usually this leads to being placed on a Spotify playlist though not a prolific listing.

As far as paid promotion to Spotify playlists go, I have tried a few, but tend to use GMP Music as they do NOT use bots etc. The results have been generally good, though sometimes it misses the target. This is due to the choice of playlist not being suitable for your music. Putting a blues track on a dedicated Hip Hop playlist will not get you far. Either way none of these offer the possiblitiy to be placed on a playlist and get honest critic, even if you do not succeed. So recently I submitted my new release 'Eyes on you' and a old release 'Me and my Baby' two very different songs to some curators on Groover. This is the first time I try this not because I wanted more playlist adds, but because I wanted to see how several curator would evaluated my music. More importently what positive-Negative critic they would come back with.
So here is the feedback from curators who did not accept my submission. This is feedback that you should listen to.
Feedback
1)
Hello there! Thanks for considering XXX. Unique style! Mystic Punk/Rock tune. Original vocals! I like the hypnotic rhythm & the atmospheric guitar, I need to pass unfortunately, because it feel´s a bit too mystic & reduced for the warmer & timeless sound I am looking for. That´s my personal taste only. Rock on & greetings!
2)
Some great ideas here... unique and original... interesting use of effects over the vocals.
I found the production just a little bit weak in parts, just my opinion.
just few spotty EQ blending moments. Solid work though, good luck.
3)
Thanks a lot for sending me your song. This is a very exciting mix of different styles, and I found it really interesting to listen to. You clearly have your own approach. It's not quite the right fit for my playlist though, so I have to pass this time. Please keep in mind that this is very subjective and simply comes down to my personal taste. It says nothing about the quality of your song. Keep doing what you do. I wish you all the best with this release.
4)
Hey there, thanks for sharing your music. I really love the warm vocals and the smooth melody you have going on here. In my opinion, you should try adding a stronger guitar riff or some punchy drums to make that main hook catchier. That extra push would really help the chorus stick in my head all day.
5)
Thank you for submitting “Eyes on You.” I found this to be a very interesting and original track. It has an experimental pop/alternative feel, and I really appreciate how unique the production, songwriting, and overall sonic direction are.
One of the things that stood out to me immediately was the vocal treatment. The effect applied to the male vocal gives the song a very distinctive character, and that’s something that is surprisingly difficult to achieve today. The vocal performance itself is excellent, particularly toward the ending, where it really adds another level of expression to the track.
From a production and mixing perspective, the song sounds solid, and I really like the fact that you’re taking some creative risks with the sound. There’s definitely an identity here.
The main issue for me is simply playlist fit. I curate two playlists, but unfortunately I don't think this track is the right match for either one. My Dirty Blues playlist is focused on blues and blues-rock guitar artists in the vein of ZZ Top, Buddy Guy, Marcus King, Eric Clapton, and other blues guitar masters. My second playlist focuses more on R&B, Neo-Soul, and artists in the vein of Erykah Badu and Jill Scott.
“Eyes on You” feels much more naturally suited to an alternative rock, experimental pop, or experimental rock playlist, where I think you could find a much stronger connection with the audience.
One suggestion for future submissions: take a few minutes to listen to several tracks from the playlist before submitting. It can really help you understand the curator's sonic direction and determine whether your song will connect with that particular audience. Finding the right playlist isn't only about getting exposure—it's about getting your music in front of the right listeners.
So unfortunately, this isn't the right home for “Eyes on You,” but that's not a reflection of the quality or originality of the song. I genuinely appreciate what you're doing creatively, and I would encourage you to pursue playlists that embrace this more experimental alternative sound.
Wishing you lots of success with “Eyes on You” and hope you find the right playlist and audience for it!
6)
I really enjoy the smooth, melodic vibe of this track, but I think adding some gritty rhythm guitars behind the chorus could push your vocal performance to sound much more raw and emotional. I hope this was helpful. All the best!
So what did I learn from this and what was the outcome.
So what did I learn. Always check what the curator is looking for and curators that match your style. Also be aware that some want videos not just a Spotify link. Set a budget and stick to it and remember that only about 30% of all submitted songs are successful. Some curator take $2 others take $6, the difference is the quality of the playlist and its reach. Here I paid $37 for 'Eyes on you' and a mix of $2-$6 per curator. The first thing I noticed and was surprised at was that the cheaper curators were the quickest to reply and gave so much more genuine feed back even if the track was not excepted, note down these curators for future submissions. Check out reply #5 above and compare to #6. The curators have 7 days to get back to you but many did not, don't worry your credits are returned.
What was the outcome ? So as you see above a very varied response that I put down to the difference in style each curator is looking for. Although no playlist placement was achieved some very important information can be derived from the feedback. The two replies #4 & 6 both think that a grittier guitar riff in the hook would lift the vocals. The same curators liked the melody and the vibe of the track . What is interesting for me is that all thought the vocals were original and interesting. Comments like, unique vocals, production, and songwriting are what should be focused on, but also maybe to record a punchy riff in the hook section would increase the songs appeal for curators.
Will write more on this as feedback comes in for 'Me and my Baby.


Comments